What We Can't Reach:
MASTERS and the Desire to Own
An imagined review, written from the working script. The publication and critic are fictional; this is not a review of a staged production.
Contains spoilersEarly in MASTERS, three young people sit on a Roxbury rooftop and write a song. The last line hangs in mid-air and never returns to the home note. The light is warm, but what really catches you is where everyone is looking: Sol looks at Eleanor, Eleanor looks at Frederick. Frederick looks at no one. He is listening.
They sit close enough to touch, and each of them wants something somewhere else. Someone says the best view in Boston is whatever we can't reach: all of it in sight, none of it in hand.
The play asks three questions: What can a person really own? What kind of music lasts? If you're right, do you win? The first two get asked out loud. The third never does, but every signature, loan and long wait is asking it.
I. Desire needs a distance
The ancient Greeks called desire sweetbitter. In MASTERS, the sweetness and the bitterness arrive together: each person reaches for something just out of reach. The distance hurts, and it also keeps the wanting from going out. The play turns this old idea into a chain, clear and cruel: Sol loves Eleanor, Eleanor loves Frederick, Frederick loves only the music. Everyone reaches forward. No one looks back.
The play never lets anyone simply get what they want. As the first act ends, Eleanor leaves Frederick, saying she knows how to want him but not how to have him. It is a parting line, and also the play's diagnosis: wanting and having are two different skills, and most of us only learn the first.
II. Three meanings of MASTERS
The title means three things.
Masters are master recordings. A master is a recording, not the song itself; but whoever controls it can often decide whether the song gets heard at all.
Masters are also the great composers. Bach, Chopin, Mozart and Dvořák all pass through the play.
And to master, as a verb, is to control.
Together they ask: who does a song belong to?
The one who wrote it? In 1999, in New York, Frederick signs a contract letting the label use his voice "in any media now known or hereafter devised." The whole room laughs: what, robots? Twenty-five years later, the robots arrive.
The one who paid for it? In 2008 Eleanor buys the masters nobody wants. That is why the songs survive, and also why they end up locked in a vault.
The one who quietly kept it? Raya puts an unclaimed recording in her cello case. Her cello is on that recording. Her name isn't on the record.
The play doesn't rule on it for us.
III. To love someone is to decide for them
The first act is about wanting; the second is about control. It is the most painful part of the play.
Thirty years on, they finally get a chance to finish the song together. This time the terms are good: Frederick's own voice, a duet with Rhodes, Raya's name restored to the credits. But once they're in the studio, he starts telling twenty-one-year-old Rhodes how to sing, where to breathe, which feeling is the correct one.
Rhodes asks: "Is that how you told my mom to play?"
He is silent for a long time.
"Every note."
Until now we have seen Frederick as the victim, a genius whose voice was taken by a contract, a label and a machine. Only here do we see that he is doing to someone else what was done to him.
Eleanor arranges his life out of love. Frederick decides how everyone's music should sound out of love too: love of the music. Sol's way looks gentler; he simply says nothing. Yet in 2008 it was Sol who secretly put up the money for Eleanor to buy Frederick's masters, and he kept it from his friend for eighteen years. Silence decides things as well: Frederick had a right to know who held his songs, and Sol decided he wouldn't.
The three of them go about it differently, but the failing is much the same: hold what you want too tightly, and you start deciding what it is allowed to become.
IV. Who can afford the cost of waiting
MASTERS gives no lectures on finance, and money is everywhere. Loans, advances, interest rates and licenses are all written into the story, but the play never stops to explain them. Money shows itself in what a person can afford, and how long they can afford to wait.
The first act is ambition, debt and a contract signed at the top of the boom. In 1999 the record business has the most profitable year in its history, and Frederick gets a one-and-a-half-million-dollar advance. A muted TV in the corner of the conference room is showing a news item about Napster. Nobody looks up. Sol tells him to take it home, read it tonight, sign tomorrow. Eleanor says that by tomorrow there will be another kid in that chair.
In 2004 the Red Sox miracle convinces the whole city that the impossible can happen. So Frederick mistakes a miracle for a plan: on parade day he walks into a bank and signs for a loan. His band calls him the human Big Dig: always one year away, and never just one year.
Sol is the other kind of person. He runs a small studio in Somerville, keeps a whole year of receipts in a peanut-butter jar, and never wants what he can't afford. On a snowy night in 2008, two people come to him for money, one after the other. He turns down his friend, who needs it to keep going, and says yes to Eleanor, who wants to buy at the bottom. She takes those masters when no one else wants them.
The second act is waiting, compounding and a mirror-image repeat. In the years of cheap money, Eleanor borrows heavily and buys up song rights by the catalog. When interest rates rise, her board tells her to sell the old songs that don't earn. She doesn't sell a single one, and the price is signing the AI license. Years ago she watched Frederick borrow and be crushed by the debt; twenty years later, on a far larger scale, she repeats his mistake. Meanwhile the unopened letters in Sol's drawer go on quietly earning interest in the dark.
The album nobody wanted in 2003 is everywhere twenty years later. A lyric in Scene 12:
You were right about the song. You were wrong about the waiting.
The music finds its listeners at last. But the years Frederick lost, and the life he thought he would have, don't come back with it. Being right isn't winning; you also have to last until you're proven right. Another line:
A city can wait eighty-six years, because it doesn't pay interest.
But the play doesn't make patience the textbook answer either. Sol can afford to wait, and he waits too long. From 2009 the letters arrive every quarter, and for seventeen years he doesn't open one, like an investment he never lets himself cash. Sometimes standing still is just fear.
In the end he opens the first letter, takes out the money and makes Rhodes a record whose masters belong to her.
Holding the rights to your own work is not the same as believing you may decide for someone else.
V. Three instruments, three people
Each of the three leads has an instrument.
Piano: Frederick. At the piano, one person can lay out melody, harmony and bass alone. Little wonder Frederick comes to mistake that completeness for not needing anyone.
His piece is Chopin's posthumous Nocturne in C-sharp minor. Chopin asked for his unpublished manuscripts to be destroyed; they came out after his death anyway, and this nocturne was published more than twenty years after he died. Whose music is a dead man's music? The question the AI Frederick raises already had an echo a hundred and fifty years ago.
The pianos around him mark the turns in his fortune: first one carried off by creditors, replaced by out-of-tune old uprights in a basement and a classroom; later a white grand in a show apartment that no one has ever played; and finally the chipped old upright in Central Square.
Cello: Sol. His sound holds up the whole ensemble, like the ground under everyone's feet. He is so dependable that people almost forget he might want to leave.
For thirty years he has played the Prelude of Bach's first Cello Suite every morning. The suites were already in print in the nineteenth century, but were long treated as practice material. In 1890 the thirteen-year-old Casals found them in a second-hand music shop in Barcelona, and practiced them for years before he brought them to the stage.
The suites had always been there; someone finally listened. Sol's life runs the same way: wait, then be heard.
Of the three instruments, only the cello never leaves its owner.
Classical guitar: Eleanor. A guitar's sound starts to fade the moment it is made; it can't be held. It is also the lightest of the three, light enough to carry when you leave home. Eleanor understood before anyone that nothing in the world can be kept, and so she spends her life trying to own things.
Her piece is Tárrega's Recuerdos de la Alhambra. Its tremolo repeats a single note so fast that a passing sound is woven into an illusion of something that never ends. The fingers never stop, so the note seems never to end. Her catalog empire works the same way.
At seventeen she closed the case. For the next thirty years the guitar stands in a lit glass cabinet in her office: visible, untouchable. That way she can go on wanting it.
Beyond the three instruments there are other voices. Raya's cello stays on someone else's record; her name doesn't. Her daughter Rhodes works with an electric piano and a laptop. Oscar builds a player piano: the sound is there, but nobody is. And Tang's guitar case in Harvard Square is always open, a few coins inside, facing across the city the case Eleanor locked behind glass.
VI. What kind of music lasts
Classical music became "classical" because it belongs to the very small part that time has sifted and still kept. MASTERS measures Frederick's songs with the same ruler, and the answer is already in the story: music lasts because there is always someone playing it, someone saving it, someone passing it on. Bach's suites waited years before anyone truly heard them; Frederick's album waited sixteen years in Raya's cello case.
The play's musical languages tell the same story. At Symphony Hall, Frederick hears Dvořák's slow movement and recognizes it as "Goin' Home," the song his mother sang all her life. The words were added later, and many people take it for an old spiritual. A melody passed through many hands until no one can quite say whose it is.
Tang plays "Romance" at the subway entrance for thirty years, a piece whose composer is still disputed; a group of students gather round him in tears, saying it's the song from a Korean drama. At Tufts, Frederick lectures on who wrote the Requiem: Mozart didn't finish it, and someone else took up his pen.
So the two lines the AI sings in Frederick's voice belong to that longer history, in which music has always been borrowed, completed, misattributed, and kept.
The problem with the AI isn't only imitation. For Frederick, the cruelty is that the voice can leave him behind and keep singing, and what it sings is no longer his to decide. In Scene 12 he asks:
How do you miss a thing that never goes away?
The sound of the whole show has its own arc. The first act belongs to streets, ballparks and studios. Hip-hop, gospel, brass and big choruses flood the stage, and the three instruments are often drowned out; the full trio is heard only once, in the first scene.
In the second act the sound is stripped away layer by layer. Beats, choirs and electronic textures leave one after another. By Scene 12 there is only one piano, and another piano that plays itself. In Scene 15 the cello and the piano finally meet again, but the guitar's part can only be hummed, softly, by Eleanor.
Not until the basement show is over does she stand alone on the empty stage and play that guitar again. Her fingers are out of practice. It is the last sound in the show played by a living person.
One more thing: the score of the whole show sounds exactly like the shelved album in the story, classical, spiritual and hip-hop woven together. In 2004 the label called it "too complicated to categorize." Right now, the audience is sitting in the theatre, listening to exactly that music.
VII. Echoes in the details
The names are instruments. Frederick shares Chopin's first name, and he made his name by rewriting Chopin's nocturnes as the sound of the future. Sol is G in solfège; Bach's first Cello Suite is in G major, and the pedal note he has held under everyone for thirty years is G too. A guitar's six open strings start on E and end on E; Eleanor is the first string and the last.
Rhodes is the name of an electric piano. The mother played a wooden cello, the daughter plays an instrument you plug in: between two generations, a migration from acoustic to electric. Raya takes her name from the cellist Raya Garbousova, who in 1946 gave the premiere of Barber's Cello Concerto with the Boston Symphony.
Oscar, who builds the AI voice, is named for the jazz pianist Oscar Peterson. He played so fast and so clean that people once suspected his records were made by a machine; the Oscar in the play actually builds one.
The Berklee kids call the street guitarist Tang "Tárrega," borrowing the name of the Spanish guitar master. The "Romance" he has played for thirty years still has no agreed composer. A borrowed name, playing a piece with no owner.
One date, three times. October 30 is the day of the 2004 championship parade, the day Frederick signs his loan, and, twenty-two years later, the night the AI comeback album goes live.
On a boat in the parade, a woman in her eighties laughs and cries at once and asks: "What am I supposed to want tomorrow?"
She waited her whole life. The moment the wish came true, the wanting ended with it. Everything the play has to say about desire is said by a minor character in the middle of a cheering city, where almost no one hears it.
A signature, a line through it. In the first act's "Sign Here," Frederick signs the clause about "any media hereafter devised." In the second act, Rhodes digs a pen out of her bag. Not a Montblanc: a plastic Dunkin' giveaway ballpoint. She strikes out the voice-license line, one stroke, perfectly straight.
Twenty-seven years: one person signs, another strikes it out. The pen that strikes it comes from the counter where Eleanor used to work. And in "The Last Signature," which falls between the two, the signature page carries a second name, and with it the play's biggest secret.
A cup of coffee. In the very first scene, someone calls Eleanor "the medium regular girl" and says Sol talks about her every morning. Thirty years later, Sol finally tells the truth about that snowy night in 2008. Frederick asks only: "How long?"
Sol answers with a coffee order:
"Medium regular. Every morning. Washington Street."
Thirty years of love never spoken, folded into a medium coffee with cream and sugar.
Instrument cases are safes. Both women hide what they treasure most in an instrument case: Eleanor keeps the 1996 tape, Raya keeps the unclaimed copy of the album. A case is meant to protect an instrument. In this play it also protects voices and histories that no one put a name to.
Two pianos. In Scene 12, two pianos in a classroom play the same Chopin. One is flawless; the other is out of tune. The out-of-tune one is played by a person. The audience discovers that its ears have quietly taken the side of the imperfect.
A song that won't go home. The song Frederick's mother sang all her life is called "Goin' Home." Yet the last line of "This Is Ours" never returns to the tonic, and in harmony the tonic is exactly what we call home.
For thirty years the song never goes home. It stops on the third: the note that decides whether a chord sounds bright or sad, and a reminder of the third person among three.
Then there are the details only Bostonians will smile at: a medium regular, a single word ("Extension"), a CharlieCard, a peanut-butter jar holding someone's ashes. They're collected under the map in the program notes.
At times these correspondences are almost too neat. The play is strongest exactly when a character makes a choice that the whole pattern can't quite explain.
VIII. The note that never falls
At the very end there are only a few dozen people in the basement. Outside, the AI comeback album lights up on millions of phones at once. For the first time, a screen spells out the name:
Cello: Raya Williams.
Rhodes reaches the last line and stops on the third. Frederick's right hand hangs above the home note. He glances at her, and doesn't press it.
That unplayed note is the first time in thirty years that Frederick doesn't decide for someone else. He lets the song stop where Rhodes wants it to stop.
The line left unfinished on a rooftop in 1996 is still unfinished in 2026. Once he couldn't reach it. Now he doesn't try.
After the basement show, Eleanor gives back the tape she hid for eighteen years. Late that night by the river, Sol and Frederick share one pair of headphones, an ear each.
On the tape, young Frederick asks:
"Wait, are we recording?"
Young Sol answers:
"Always."
On the tape, the three of them are still laughing.
★★★★★