MASTERS← Home
Scene 12Act II · Bitter2025A classroom at Tufts

Just Not to Me

Two pianos · soul ballad
Listen · tap a line to jump there
0:00 / 3:44
Play all from here →

Frederick is lecturing on who really wrote Mozart's Requiem when a donated player piano starts his "new single." His students sing along to words he never wrote. Two pianos play the same nocturne: one perfect, one out of tune. At the door stands the boy from the basement, grown: "I made that voice." Frederick puts on his coat. "If those songs are coming out again, I'm the one singing them."

“How do you miss a thing that never goes away?”

Lyrics · Scene 12
Frederick

I used to sing to empty rooms.

Now strangers know the words.

I spent my life becoming heard,

and nobody heard me.

The Voice

I used to sing to empty rooms.

Now strangers know the words.

Frederick

It sounds like me at twenty-five.

It never cracks, it never tires.

It's got my voice, and none of my mistakes,

so tell me which of us is real.

It never leaves, it's everywhere,

so nobody has to wait for it,

and how do you miss a thing

that never goes away?

Whole world's singing my song,

just not to me.

Everywhere I go,

there's a piece of what I used to be.

On the radio, in the elevator,

on a stranger's phone in a stranger's hand,

whole world's singing my song.

Just not to me.

Young Frederick

You call it strange,

they'll call it new.

Just give the world a year or two.

Frederick

It took twenty, kid.

You were right about the song.

You were wrong about the waiting.

Early is a kind of wrong

that turns right when you're gone.

The note I always missed in the second line,

the breath I took too soon,

the place my voice would break a little

every time I sang to you:

that was me. That was the part

no one could ever copy down.

Now the copy's in the window,

and the man is in the crowd.

Frederick

I gave it everything.

It gave it back to everyone

but me.

I was right.

I wish I hadn't needed to be.